Strategic Culture of Turkey before the AKP Rule and its Reflections to Turkish Foreign Policy
Keywords:strategic culture, Turkey, security mentality, Independence War, national security
Turkey has been in the center of global developments during the last century because of its geographical location. The sense of being surrounded by enemies is the most important characteristic of the Turkish strategic culture pre-AKP period which has been named Republican strategic culture. In this line, in the literature, it is believed that the Turkish security policy is decisive and inflexible. Looking at the history of Turkey, it can be seen that this determination and lack of trust in others is the product of its strategic culture. This means that Turkish politicians will pursue the goal in any possible way until they achieve the desired result. Thus, one of the characteristics of Turkeyâ€™s strategic culture in the last century was the lack of trust in rivals and neighbours. Factors such as the continuous wars with Russia and other neighbours, the betrayal by some citizens in the Middle East and Balkans, and the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, incitement of minorities by rivals and Turkeyâ€™s suspicions of neighbours and great powers in the form of strategic culture have influenced Turkish foreign policy since the establishment of the Republic of Turkey in 1923 to 2002. This importance is to extent that Turkey refused to enter the Second World War and pursued a decisive policy to defend its interests in some historical stages, such as the Cyprus crisis in the 1970s. Thus, this article reviews the Turkish strategic culture in the last century and its evolution process.Â
Aday Memur HazÄ±rlayÄ±cÄ± EÄŸitimi. (2019). T.C.â€™nin Ulusal GÃ¼venlik PolitikalarÄ± ve GÃ¼venlik Stratejilerin GeliÅŸimi [Turkeyâ€™s National Security Policy and Development of Security Strategy]. Turkish Ministry of Justice, Retrieved from https://edb.adalet.gov.tr/e-book/3-ULUSALG%C3%9CVENL%C4%B0K.pdf
Alaranta, T. (2014). Contemporary Kemalism from Universal Secular-Humanism to Extreme Turkish Nationalism. New York: Routledge.
AkÃ§ay, E. (2015). Transformasyonel Diplomasi ve Ã–zal EkolÃ¼. [Transformational Diplomacy and Ã–zal School]. In E. Ertosun & E. DemirbaÅŸ (Ed.), Turgut Ã–zal; DeÄŸiÅŸim, DÃ¶nÃ¼ÅŸÃ¼m [Turgut Ã–zal; Change, Transformation] (169-190). Ankara: Turgut Ã–zal Ãœniversitesi YayÄ±nlarÄ±.
Alaranta, T. (2018). The â€˜New Turkeyâ€™ As A NATO Member. FIIA Working Paper, 103, 2018.
AltÄ±nay, A. G. (2004). The Myth of the Military Nation. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004.
ArÄ±, T. & PirinÃ§Ã§i, F. (2010). Turkeyâ€™s New Foreign Policy towards the Middle East and the Perceptions in Syria and Lebanon. Akademik BakÄ±ÅŸ, 4 (7): 1-16.
Arslan, A. (2006). The Turkish Power Elite, International Journal of Human Sciences, 3(1): 1-19.
BaÅŸbakanlÄ±k. (2003). TÃ¼rk Gencinin El KitabÄ±, AtatÃ¼rk Ã–ÄŸÃ¼tleri [Turkish Youth Handbook, AtatÃ¼rkâ€™s Advices]. Ankara: Halkla Ä°liÅŸkiler Genel MÃ¼dÃ¼rlÃ¼ÄŸÃ¼.
Bilge, A. S. (1997). An Analysis of Turkish â€“ Russian Relations. SAM Center for Strategic Research.
Burak, B. (2001). The Role of the Military in Turkish Politics: To Guard Whom and From What?. European Journal of Economic and Political Studies, 4(1): 143-169.
Danforth, N. (2008). Ideology and Pragmatism in Turkish Foreign Policy: From AtatÃ¼rk to the AKP. Turkish Policy Quarterly, 7(3): 83-95.
DavutoÄŸlu, A. (2002). KÃ¼resel BunalÄ±m; 11 EylÃ¼l KonuÅŸmalarÄ± [Global Crisis; September 11 Speeches]. Faruk Deniz (Ed.), 3. Edition, Ä°stanbul: KÃ¼re YayÄ±nlarÄ±.
Dimitrakis, P. (2008). Intelligence for Crisis Management: The Case of the January 1996 Greekâ€“Turkish Crisis. European Security, 17 (4): 455-493.
Dorronsoro, G. & Gourisse, B. (2015). Institutional Autonomy, the Formation of Social Coalitions, and the Production of Crises. Revue FranÃ§aise de Science Politique (English Edition), 65(4): 67-88.
ErdaÄŸ, R. & KardaÅŸ, T. (2012). TÃ¼rk DÄ±ÅŸ PolitikasÄ± ve Stratejik KÃ¼ltÃ¼r.â€ [Turkish Foreign Policy and Strategic Culture], TÃ¼rk DÄ±ÅŸ PolitikasÄ± YÄ±llÄ±ÄŸÄ±: 66-90.
Evans, R. (2014). Turkeyâ€™s Shifting Strategic Culture: Part 2 â€“ the Rise of Republican Strategic Culture. The Foreign Policy Research Institute, Retrieved from https://www.fpri.org/2014/10/turkeys-shifting-strategic-culture-part-2-the-rise-of-republican-strategic-culture/
Evans, R. (2014). Turkeyâ€™s Shifting Strategic Culture: Part 3 â€“ from Republican to Neo-Ottoman. The Foreign Policy Research Institute, Retrieved from https://www.fpri.org/2014/10/turkeys-shifting-strategic-culture-part-3-from-republican-to-neo-ottoman/
GÃ¼ndÃ¼z, G. (2017). Militarising School: Militarism in the Turkish Educational System (1926â€“1947). Paedagogica Historica, 54(3): 1-14.
Marcus, T. (2015). Turkey: Conceptual Framework. Ideology, Strategic Culture, and National Security. Macedonian league, Retrieved from http://www.macedonianleague.org/news/turkey-conceptual-framework-ideology-strategic-culture-and-national-security.
McGhe, G. (1990). the US-Turkish-NATO Middle East Connection How the Truman Doctrine Contained the Soviets in the Middle East, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
MKK. (2015). Milli GÃ¼venlik Kurulu, 29 Nisan 2015 Tarihinde ToplantÄ±sÄ±nÄ± YapmÄ±ÅŸtÄ±r [National Security Council Held Its Meeting on 29 April 2015]. Secretariat-General of the National Security Council. Retrieved from https://www.mgk.gov.tr/index.php/29-nisan-2015-tarihli-toplanti
Mufti, M. (2009). Daring and Caution in Turkish Strategic Culture, Republic at Sea. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Oztig, L. I. (2019). Syria and Turkey: Borderâ€Security Priorities.â€ Middle East Policy, XXVI(1): 117-126.
Ã–zdemir, E. (2006). TÃ¼rk DÄ±ÅŸ Politika YapÄ±mÄ± SÃ¼recinde SilahlÄ± Kuvvetlerin RolÃ¼ (1990-2005) [the Role of the Armed Forces in the Process of Turkish Foreign Policy Making (1990-2005)]. (Masterâ€™s Thesis, Selcuk University). Turkey: Selcuk University.
Renda, K. K. (2011). Learning New Roles and Changing Beliefs: Turkish Strategic Culture in Transition. CES 18th International Conference of European Studies, Guildford: University Association for Contemporary European Studies.
The Guardian. â€œRussian Serviceman with Shouldered Rocket Launcher â€˜Seen on Bosphorus. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/dec/06/russian-serviceman-with-shouldered-rocket-launcher-seen-on-bosphorus.
The Irish Times. (1996). Admiral sacked after Aegean dispute. Retrieved from https://www.irishtimes.com/news/admiral-sacked-after-aegean-dispute-1.29394
Ulgul, M. (2010). The Soviet Influence on Turkish Foreign Policy (1945-1960).â€ (Masterâ€™s Thesis, The Florida State University). the United States: The Florida State University.
Ãœrer, L. (2003). Rethinking Turkish-American Relations as a Component of the Turkish Foreign Policy towards the USSR from the Cold War until Today. Ä°stanbul Ãœniversitesi YakÄ±n DÃ¶nem TÃ¼rkiye AraÅŸtÄ±rmalarÄ± Dergisi 3: 269-278.
YeÅŸiltaÅŸ, M. (2012). TÃ¼rkiyeâ€™yi KonumlandÄ±rmak: Jeopolitik Zihniyet ve TÃ¼rkiyeâ€™de Ordu. [Locating Turkey: Geopolitical Mentality and the Army in Turkey]. (Doctorate Thesis, Marmara University), Turkey: Marmara University.
YÄ±ldÄ±rÄ±m, Ã‡. (2010). the Role of the Military in Turkish Politics and European Union Membership Negotiations. Balkan Analysis, http://www.balkanalysis.com/turkey/2010/12/02/the-role-of-themilitary-in-turkish-politics-and-european-union-membership-negotiations/.
ZÃ¼rcher, E. J. (2017). Turkey: A Modern History. 4th edition, I.B.Tauris: London and New York.